🗓️Published on: 05/11/2026
The 2019 incident at the Oran Court of Appeal began on the morning of Sunday, 3 November, when the National Gendarmerie intervened inside the courthouse during a protest by magistrates. The following day, the Ministry of Justice announced an investigation to establish responsibility for what had happened. Seven years later, the ministry's statement remains publicly available. Yet, as of the publication of this report, we have found no document among the official and media sources reviewed that discloses the investigation's findings or establishes whether any disciplinary or judicial action followed.
How Did the Oran Court of Appeal Incident Begin?
The dispute began in October 2019 over a judicial reshuffle affecting approximately 3,000 magistrates, according to Algerian Radio. The Ministry of Justice described the reshuffle as a routine administrative process in which transfer requests were taken into consideration. The National Union of Magistrates (SNM) called for a work stoppage. On 26 October, the ministry responded by invoking Article 12 of the statute governing the judiciary at the time, which prohibited magistrates from taking any action that would suspend or obstruct judicial proceedings. Algerian Radio's coverage andthe Ministry of Justice's response.
On the morning of 3 November, striking magistrates gathered to oppose the opening of the criminal court session and the formal installation of magistrates affected by the reshuffle. The newspaper El Khabar reported that the public prosecutor's office had called in security forces and that intervention personnel forcibly opened several offices. The news website Tout sur l'Algérie (TSA) published footage recorded inside the courthouse. Algerian Radio, meanwhile, reported that the striking magistrates had attempted to prevent the session from opening before a public-order unit intervened. These contemporary accounts remain among the principal sources documenting the events at the Oran Court of Appeal. Footage of the intervention andAlgerian Radio's account.
The Photograph of a Female Magistrate and Its Place in Trade Union Memory
COSYFOP received a photograph showing a woman with visible redness on her cheek. According to the account accompanying the image, she was a magistrate who had been slapped by a gendarme during the protest. Contemporary sources confirm that the gendarmerie intervened, and the National Union of Magistrates reported injuries. However, we have found no published testimony from the woman pictured, no footage documenting the alleged slap, and no investigation report identifying the person responsible.
The Investigation into the Oran Court of Appeal Incident and the Trade Unions' Response
On 4 November 2019, the Ministry of Justice announced that it had ordered an in-depth investigation to establish the facts, determine responsibility and prevent a recurrence. Its statement neither identified an individual officer nor referred to the alleged slap. While the announcement confirms that an investigation was ordered, its outcome remains unknown on the basis of the available sources. The absence of published findings does not, in itself, establish that no one was prosecuted or sanctioned. Ministry of Justice statement on the Oran Court of Appeal incident.
Statements issued on the day of the intervention show that the National Union of Magistrates condemned the use of force and reported assaults and injuries. The National Union of Lawyers' Organisations also denounced the violation of the judiciary's inviolability, while the Arab Union of Judges called for the protection of Algerian magistrates. As for the woman pictured, we found no public statement establishing whether any trade union organisation had offered her legal assistance or pursued a complaint with her consent. The possibility that assistance was provided privately cannot be ruled out. Statement by the National Union of Magistrates andthe lawyers' response andthe Arab Union of Judges' position.
Two days after the Oran Court of Appeal incident, the National Union of Magistrates announced the end of the strike following an agreement with the ministry. The agreement addressed professional and financial demands and provided for discussions on revising legislation relating to judicial independence. The Judges' Club objected to the decision to end the strike, describing it as unilateral. Magistrates returned to their courts, but the investigation announced by the ministry the previous day still required follow-up independent of the agreement to resume work. Announcement ending the strike andthe Judges' Club's response.
Who Represents Magistrates in Algeria?
The National Union of Magistrates (SNM) features in official consultations with the Ministry of Justice, which received its executive committee in December 2024 and held a further meeting with it in November 2025. However, the register of trade union organisations reveals that a second organisation representing magistrates was registered in the early 1990s. The annex to the Friedrich Ebert Foundation's study Trade Unions in Algeria lists both organisations under entries 56 and 57. Ministry of Justice meeting with the union andregister of trade union organisations.
The organisation holding registration receipt No. 33 is distinct from the Judges' Club, which publicly expressed its position following the Oran Court of Appeal incident. In 2020, El Khabar described the club as having been in the process of establishment since 2016. We found no document conclusively explaining why the Union of Algerian Magistrates was absent from the official consultations we reviewed. Establishing whether it ceased operating, was suspended or was dissolved by court order would require clarification from the Ministry of Labour and documentation from the union's last known representatives.
What Rights Does Article 20 Guarantee Magistrates Today?
Article 20 of Organic Law No. 26-03 of 23 March 2026 recognises the trade union rights of magistrates in accordance with the legislation in force. It links the exercise of those rights to respect for the dignity of judicial office, the integrity and independence of the judiciary, and the continuity of the administration of justice. Principle 9 of the United Nations Basic Principles on the Independence of the Judiciary also recognises the freedom of judges to form and join organisations representing their interests and protecting their independence. Algeria has ratified International Labour Organization Convention No. 87 concerning Freedom of Association and Protection of the Right to Organise. Official Gazette andUnited Nations principles on judicial independence andILO conventions ratified by Algeria.
The importance of these guarantees becomes particularly clear when revisiting the Oran Court of Appeal incident. A magistrate challenging a transfer needs to understand the criteria behind the decision and know which body is responsible for examining the objection. A magistrate subjected to violence needs an institution capable of pursuing the case until a response is obtained. Litigants, too, have a direct interest in ensuring that magistrates can challenge pressure threatening their independence without having to confront, alone, the authority responsible for decisions affecting their professional careers.
How Could the Union of Algerian Magistrates Resume Its Activities?
- Retrieve the records relating to registration receipt No. 33. The first step is to gather the original registration receipt, the union's statutes and the most recent minutes of its elections or congress. A written request should then be submitted to the Ministry of Labour to establish the union's officially recorded status and obtain copies of any administrative decision or court ruling affecting its activities.
- Identify who is authorised to convene the members. If the union is found to remain legally in existence, its statutes must determine who may convene a general assembly, the conditions governing membership, quorum requirements and electoral procedures. If a dissolution judgment or suspension decision is identified, its legal consequences and the available avenues for review must be examined before any meeting is convened in the organisation's name.
- Review compliance with the current legal framework. The Ministry of Labour required trade union organisations established under previous legislation to bring their statutes into conformity with Article 159 of Law No. 23-02. It is therefore necessary to establish what documents, if any, were submitted on behalf of the union and what responses were received. If resuming its activities proves impossible, magistrates may consider establishing a new organisation in accordance with the applicable legal requirements. Law 23-02 andCOSYFOP's analysis of the exercise of trade union rights.
Seven Years After the Oran Court of Appeal Incident: What Questions Remain Unanswered?
The Ministry of Justice still has an opportunity to clarify the outcome of the investigation into the Oran Court of Appeal incident. The National Union of Magistrates can also document any steps it took following its condemnation of the intervention, while respecting the wishes and privacy of those concerned. The Ministry of Labour, for its part, can clarify the current legal status of the organisation holding registration receipt No. 33. Together, these records would help complete the public account of an incident that concerns both the magistrates who experienced the intervention and every citizen who has a legitimate interest in understanding how judges are protected when they themselves seek justice.
Video: Revisiting the 2019 Oran Court of Appeal Incident
If the video does not play here, you can watch it directly on YouTube. Watch on YouTube
📬 Did you like this article? Subscribe to our newsletter to receive the latest news and important information directly to your inbox.